Top 5 Golf Courses in New York: An In-Depth Guide (2024)

New York State is a golfer's paradise, boasting a wide variety of courses that cater to different skill levels and preferences. Whether you are a seasoned professional or a casual golfer, the state offers some of the best golf experiences in the world. Here's an expanded look at the top five golf courses in New York, providing you with detailed insights into what makes each one unique and worth visiting. Plus, don't miss out on the Top 10 Golf Travel Destinations in the USA to expand your golfing adventures beyond New York.

1. Bethpage Black Course

• Location: Farmingdale, Long Island

• Designed By: A.W. Tillinghast

• Course Type: Public

• Length: 7,468 yards

• Par: 71

Highlights

• Global Recognition: Bethpage Black is often ranked among the top golf courses globally. It has hosted prestigious tournaments such as the U.S. Open and the PGA Championship, earning a reputation as one of the most challenging courses in the United States.

• A True Test of Skill: The course is notorious for its difficulty. It features narrow fairways, strategically placed bunkers, and complex greens. The famous sign at the first tee warns golfers: "The Black Course is an extremely difficult course which we recommend only for highly skilled golfers."

• Public Access: One of the standout features of Bethpage Black is that it's a public course. This means that, with some planning, anyone can experience this world-class course without needing to be a member or have insider connections. This accessibility adds to its appeal and mystique.

Why It's Special?

Bethpage Black's combination of public accessibility and professional-level challenge is rare. Its beautifully maintained layout and the prestige of playing on a course where golfing legends have competed make it a bucket-list destination for avid golfers. The course's natural landscape, with its rolling terrain and lush greenery, provides a scenic backdrop that enhances the overall experience.

2. Shinneco*ck Hills Golf Club

• Location: Southampton, Long Island

• Designed By: William Flynn (current design)

• Course Type: Private

  See Also

  Golfweek's Best Courses You Can Play 2024: Top 100 U.S. public-access layouts, rankedA golf major hosted at a bowling alley? Why Sahalee has pros going wildThe best golf tech in 2024: Launch monitors, rangefinders, simulators, watches and moreBeyond the birdie: 5 best golf courses in Australia

• Length: 7,440 yards

• Par: 70

Highlights

• Rich History: Shinneco*ck Hills is one of the oldest golf clubs in America, with a history dating back to 1891. It has been a site for the U.S. Open multiple times, reflecting its enduring significance in the golfing world.

• Traditional Links Layout: The course is designed in a classic links style, characterized by wide fairways, rolling hills, and minimal tree coverage. This design, which is reminiscent of the traditional courses in Scotland, offers a unique golfing experience that differs from typical parkland courses.

• Wind Challenge: Located near the Atlantic Ocean, Shinneco*ck Hills is known for its windy conditions. The wind can significantly affect play, adding an extra layer of challenge that tests even the most experienced golfers.

Why It's Special?

Shinneco*ck Hills combines historical charm with a challenging, beautiful layout. Playing here feels like stepping back in time, with the course's design reflecting the traditional principles of golf. The natural beauty and open landscape, coupled with the unpredictable wind, provide a golfing experience that is both visually stunning and technically demanding.

3. Winged Foot Golf Club (West Course)

• Location: Mamaroneck, Westchester County

• Designed By: A.W. Tillinghast

• Course Type: Private

• Length: 7,477 yards

• Par: 72

Highlights

• Prestigious History: Winged Foot's West Course has a storied history of hosting major golf championships, including the U.S. Open and PGA Championship. The course is synonymous with top-level competition and has been a battleground for many legendary moments in golf.

• Challenging Design: The West Course is renowned for its demanding layout. Tillinghast's design incorporates deep bunkers, narrow fairways, and undulating greens that require precision and strategic thinking. Each hole presents a unique challenge, making the course a true test of golfing skill.

• Exclusive Access: As a private club, access to Winged Foot is limited to members and their guests. This exclusivity adds to the course's allure and makes playing here a special experience for those who have the opportunity.

Why It's Special?

Winged Foot's West Course stands out for its challenging design and historical significance. The meticulous maintenance of the course ensures that it is always in pristine condition, providing a top-notch playing experience. The sense of tradition and exclusivity at Winged Foot makes it a coveted destination for golfers around the world.

4. Oak Hill Country Club (East Course)

• Location: Rochester, Upstate New York

• Designed By: Donald Ross

• Course Type: Private

• Length: 7,145 yards

• Par: 70

Highlights

• Major Championship Venue: Oak Hill's East Course has a long history of hosting major championships, including the PGA Championship, U.S. Open, and Ryder Cup. The course's reputation for excellence is cemented by its association with these high-profile events.

• Classic Design: Donald Ross, one of the most respected course designers in golf history, crafted the East Course with an emphasis on strategic play. The course features small, fast greens and tight fairways that require accurate shot-making and careful planning.

• Beautiful Landscape: The course is set in a picturesque landscape, with tree-lined fairways and carefully manicured greens. The natural beauty of the area, combined with the thoughtful design, creates a serene and challenging environment for golfers.

Why It's Special?

Oak Hill's East Course is a masterpiece of classic golf course design. Its history of hosting major tournaments and the beauty of its layout make it a must-play for serious golfers. The course's combination of challenge, tradition, and scenic beauty provides a memorable golfing experience.

5. The Links at Union Vale

• Location: Lagrangeville, Hudson Valley

• Designed By: Stephen Kay and Doug Smith

• Course Type: Public

• Length: 6,889 yards

• Par: 72

Highlights

• Public Accessibility: The Links at Union Vale is a public course, making it accessible to all golfers without the need for a membership. This openness allows a broader audience to enjoy a high-quality golfing experience.

• Scottish Links Feel: Designed to emulate the traditional Scottish links courses, The Links at Union Vale features wide-open fairways, minimal trees, and strategic bunkers. The course's design encourages a different style of play, focusing on creativity and shot-making.

• Scenic Countryside Views: The course is set in the beautiful Hudson Valley, offering stunning views of the surrounding countryside. The natural landscape is incorporated into the course design, providing a tranquil and visually appealing backdrop for a round of golf.

Why It's Special?

The Links at Union Vale offers a unique golfing experience with its links-style design and public accessibility. The course's layout and scenic beauty make it a delightful destination for golfers of all levels. It provides a taste of traditional Scottish golf in the heart of New York's countryside, making it a standout choice for those looking to enjoy a high-quality, public golf course.

Final Thoughts

Each of these top five golf courses in New York offers a distinct experience, from the public challenge of Bethpage Black to the historical prestige of Shinneco*ck Hills and Winged Foot. Whether you're looking for a tough test of your skills or a beautiful, relaxing round in scenic surroundings, these courses have something to offer every golfer.

• Bethpage Black Course: Ideal for golfers seeking a challenging round on a world-famous public course.

• Shinneco*ck Hills Golf Club: Perfect for those who appreciate historical courses with a traditional links feel.

• Winged Foot Golf Club: A must-play for golfers who value prestigious, exclusive courses with complex layouts.

• Oak Hill Country Club: Great for golfers who enjoy classic course designs and a rich tournament history.

• The Links at Union Vale: Best for golfers looking for a unique, accessible course with a Scottish links vibe and beautiful scenery.

No matter which course you choose, you're in for an unforgettable golfing experience in New York State.